I happened to be up late last night, bored, surfing the television channels for something more interesting than the incessant re-runs of Law and Order. I came upon a documentary concerning free speech in America, both historically and today. I'm sorry to say that I did not jot down the film's title.
I must say that the documentary provided a very even-handed account. There was perhaps a hint of liberal bias; still, it attempted to be fair in its presentation. If there had not been a hint of liberal bias there would have been a hint of conservative bias, or religious bias or... None of us suffer from zero preconceptions.
One segment of the film had to do with an Immigrant woman from Yemen. She had been brought to the United States by her parents at the age of three. I suppose she is now 40 years old or more. She appeared in all regards to be intelligent, well-educated, gentle and yet passionately committed to her profession and job as an Assistant School principal in New York City.
She had been chosen by the school board to become the principal of a bi-lingual school for Arab students. Her's was one of some 40 schools planned to address the needs of the many immigrant students of all nationalities, creeds, religions and cultures to be found in New York City.
As news of the impending opening of the school began to spread into the mainstream press this woman came under heavy attack from many sides of the political, religious and social spectrum. She was denounced as a hater of any religion other than Islam. She was portrayed as a zealot whose motives were pro-Arab and perhaps even pro-terrorist. Her school to be was described as a potential training ground for more zealots, and on and on. She was accused of saying that 9/11 never happened although she lived in the city and was present there on 9/11.
None of these accusations appear to have been true. Whether or not the public school system should set up special schools for the many ethnic and religious factions living in this country is another matter.
The issue here is that the press, at the bidding of a few powerful, ultra-conservatives, destroyed this woman's career. Not only did the school never open, she was asked to resign. Her supporters on the school board and in the Mayor's office did nothing to come to her aid. In the end they let one particularly zealous reporter ruin this woman.
I have some familiarity with this scenario. I find it very difficult to believe anything that I read in the newspapers or watch on television news.
There have been, over the course of 40 years, many stories (stories in which I played some role and of which I had intimate knowledge of the facts and details) aired on television or written up in the news, in which the facts were distorted, the details wrong, and the conclusions drawn wrong-headed and harmful. I have never known a reporter to get it all just right.
Perhaps the postmodernists are correct. There is no truth, only competing narratives.
The principal did not get a fair shake, she was allowed to speak on her own behalf, but her words never reached the public. They were distorted, taken out of context and butchered by the press.
Free speech isn't worth very much if there is no forum in which to speak it.
Recent Comments